There are many reasons to object to privatization.
1. One is that there is no evidence that privately managed firms that operate public services provide more efficient or less costly service.
2. Another is that privately managed firms, when operating for profit, extract public dollars for investors that taxpayers intended for children, for educational programs that directly benefit children, for reduced class sizes, ---and not to enrich shareholders.
3. Privately managed nonprofits often pay salaries that would be unacceptable in the public sector.
4. Privately managed firms tend to exclude the costliest clients to minimize their own costs, thus leaving the hardest cases for the less well funded public sector agency.
5. And last, to destroy public education, which is so inextricably linked to our notions of democracy and citizenship would be an assault on the commonweal.
Let us not forget that public education has been the instrument of the great social movements for more than the past half century--desegregation, gender equality, disability rights, and the assimilation of immigrants. Once it is gone, it is gone, and that would be a crime against ourselves.
The reader writes:
"Ladd and Fiske correctly identify the four risks to the public education system of the privatization movement, but they assume that the public education system is an unqualified "good." What if privatization produces different and better goods? Public education implements mainly a "progressive" philosophy of government. By the word "democracy" it means government control of education and almost everything else it can get its hands on. "Social justice" is the well-worn substitute term for 'redistribute the wealth.' I mean no name calling to point out that has been the communist agenda from the beginning and remains the communist agenda.
"The whole point of privatization, then, is to free American education from the statist agenda (which implies 'community' responsiblity for every individual and submission of every individual to the tyranny of the community). Most here see public education as an unmixed good. It's opponents think otherwise, and their motives are clear.
"What is most surprising, however, is to find the Obama Education Department so staunchly behind the measures that we ALL agree are destroying the public school systems. NCLB? RTTT? CCSS?
What true educator can support that testing to extinction? It baffles me why Obama/Duncan want to eliminate the public school systems when their objectives in every other area of life, especially health care, is anti individual freedom.
"Ladd and Fiske, then, are totally correct in saying that the privatization movement sees public goods as merely the sum of the individual goods arising from education. I say that is the way it should be in America.
What are claimed as social goods lost by privatization are, in my view, really social "bads." They are mainly accustoming citizens to acquiesce in state control of their lives. There's been enough of that already."
Thursday, January 3, 2013
Is Privatization of Public Schools a Good Idea?
From the Journal of Education Finance , Fall 2012 by Kern Alexander The story goes that tuition voucher schools and charter schools a...
by Robert Slater High-stakes tests and testing policies are now being reinforced with value-added teacher assessment. But gains in te...
B Y J A M I E R O B E R T V O L L M E R America’s public schools can be traced back to the year 1640. The Massachusetts Purit...
Reflections on a Half-Century of School Reform: Why Have We Fallen Short and Where Do We Go From Here?By Jack Jennings, President and CEO, Center on Education Policy When I studied history in college, I was impressed by those few individual...
Local School Boards to Duncan: Back Off! by Diane Ravitch The U.S. Department of Education is not supposed to control U.S. education...
by D iane Ravitch North Carolina is a plum market for the online for-profit charter industry. Today, the state board of education ...
b y JULIE UNDERWOOD (Editor's note: Through the corporate-funded American Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC), global corporati...
Jack Hassard Source: The Art of Teaching Science Today, a committee in Georgia Senate will discuss the Parent...
Cartoons on Common Core Standards by Larry Cuban For this monthly* post of cartoons, I have selected images about the impending Commo...
Glass, Gene V (2008-06-01). Fertilizers, Pills & Magnetic Strips The Fate of Public Education in America From Chapter 8: Eight Reformi...